Monday, March 18, 2013

Reds could choose option 3 in Chapman decision

Without a doubt, the biggest story in Reds camp this spring is whether Aroldis Chapman will start or close. After the Cuban defector voiced is preference to return to the bullpen Saturday, general manager Walt Jocketty stated a decision would be forthcoming this week. Jocketty went on to say the organization would consider Chapman's wishes, but "we don't let every player tell us how they want to be used."

If Cincinnati Enquirer columnist Paul Daughtery is accurate that their are those within the organization who aren't sold Todd Frazier can be the club's everyday third baseman, it has been obvious from the quotes this spring that a similar divide exists regarding Chapman.  While he's never tipped his hand, it's a safe guess, Jocketty would like to see how Chapman would fare in the rotation while Dusty Baker prefers having his power arm to close out games.

I've maintained all along, this spring is no different than last year, where Chapman was one of the better starters in camp -- and would have began the year in the rotation had the team not had all the injuries to the bullpen.  Chapman could always go back to the pen.  The danger in starting Chapman in the rotation this season is if it doesn't go well, it could cost the team games in the standings.  While it would be difficult to leave someone with his power arm off the roster, perhaps the best course of action is to have Chapman begin the year in the minors.  That way the organization could see how Chapman adjusts to starting without costing the big league club games in the process.  If it doesn't work out, (say after 2 months) the team could always recall him and return him to the bullpen.

I know the counter argument to this scenario and I tend to agree this team is best with Broxton pitching in the eighth and Chapman in the ninth.  However, Broxton filled the ninth inning role capably when Chapman had to rest a tired shoulder late last year and I think Broxton can do well as the closer for a short period of time.  Afterall he's been a closer much of his career and it's why the Reds re-signed him this offseason.  But he's proven to be better in big moments as a set-up guy.

The risk is if Chapman performs well as a starter in the minors, the club would then be forced to use Broxton full-time in the closer's role, and you likely kick out a capable member of the rotation (most likely Mike Leake).  But at least then, the team would be able to quantify what the Cuban Missile can do as starter.

2 comments:

  1. I think the greater issue is Walt vs Dusty in public statements , they need to be on the same page & not have this public divide!
    2 Hit B

    ReplyDelete
  2. Is Bronson's hand alright? I heard he can't play the guitar or with himself on the mound anymore. (he grabs his crotch frequently ont he mound).

    ReplyDelete